v. 19 - Consequences of being filled with the Spirit.
1. Singing and making melody
2. Giving of thanks - v.20
3. Subjection one to others - v.21.
speaking [addressing] -- In singing giving admonition to self and others, directed to the Lord.
1) Ourselves - Teach, exhortation, admonish
2) To God - praise, glory, thanks.
one another -- Christian singing in worship should edify self and others and be to the praise and glory of God.
psalms and hymns and spiritual songs -- While some see all three categories as parts of the Book of Psalms, we understand only psalms to mean the inspired writings of David, Asaph, and others. Hymns are non-inspired songs which ascribe worship and praise directly to God. Spiritual songs are any other lyrical compositions dealing with spiritual themes, even though not addressed directly to God. - BBC
spiritual songs -- Spiritual “odes” - ᾠδᾶις ōdais. Odes or songs relating to spiritual things in contradistinction from these which were sung in places of festivity and revelry. - BN
E. Wellesz proposed that the terms were specific in meaning. He defined psalmody as “the cantillation of the Jewish psalms and of the canticles and doxologies modeled on them”; hymns as “songs of praise of a syllabic type, i.e. each syllable is sung to one or two notes of melody”; and spiritual songs as “Alleluias and other chants of a jubilant or ecstatic character, richly ornamented” (Wellesz 1955, 2).
...
Wellesz was aware of the view that the three words are synonyms but suggests that “the individuality of psalm, hymn, and spiritual song is obvious to the student of comparative liturgiology” (Wellesz 1961, 33–34)
...
Most scholars think that the Jewish psalmody of the synagogue is what the first Christians sang, and as the earliest Christians were Jews, it is reasonable to think that Jewish psalmody was the basis of their music.
Porter, W. J. (2000). Music. In C. A. Evans & S. E. Porter (Eds.), Dictionary of New Testament background: a compendium of contemporary biblical scholarship (electronic ed., p. 713). Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press.
making melody -- ψαλμός -- psalmós; genitive psalmoú, masculine noun from psállō (G5567), to sing, chant "Music" in the NIV
In 1 Corinthians 14:15 --(See the context there.) Singing with the Spirit may be a reference to supernatural or miraculous inspiration.
your heart -- The instrument that is "plucked" in the "making melody" is described as the "heart." In the OT when there is "plucking" the instrument is named, as it is here.
Christian singing is to be accompanied by the heart. For singing to be spiritual worship it must have the heart involved in its praise to God. Colossians 2:2.
to the Lord -- The contrast is between the heathen and the Christian practice, "Let your songs be not the drinking songs of heathen feasts, but psalms and hymns; and their accompaniment, not the music of the lyre, but the melody of the heart" - Conybeare and Howson.
A Common Hermeneutic
A specific commandment authorizes; silence about similar things prohibits. The apostolic command is to sing; silence about other kinds of music intentionally omits them.
That is a common hermeneutic we all learned as children. When Mama said, "Go play in the backyard," "backyard" was specific. It commanded an enjoyable and familiar play place. We learned quickly that her silence about other play places prohibited: playing in the street or inside Philip’s house next door, for example.
Why do we understand that so readily in every other venue except in worship to God?
-- Cecil May, Jr.
singing and making melody in your heart to the Lord. -- A second evidence of the filling is inward joy and praise to God: singing and making melody in your heart to the Lord. The Spirit-filled life is a fountain, bubbling over with joy (Acts 13:52). Zacharias is an illustration: when he was filled with the Holy Spirit, he sang with all his heart to the Lord (Luke 1:67-79). - BBC
[For a more extensive explanation for the practice of a capella music in Christian worship see the e-Sword module at http://http://home.hiwaay.net/~wgann/e-Sword Modules/e-Sword index.htm
or to download a PDF click here.
http://home.hiwaay.net/~wgann/sermons/ACAPPELLA MUSIC IN NT WORSHIP - 5x8 booklet.pdf