Verses 1–6
God’s Spirit and the Spirit of the Antichrist
1 John 4:1. In the last verse of the previous chapter John has already highlighted the fact that you have the Holy Spirit. There he mentions Him as an emphasis of the security that God abides in you. In the section you now have in front of you he will put the work of God’s Spirit against the work of the antichrist.
You can discern what comes from God’s Spirit and what comes from the spirit of the antichrist by asking for the confession of Jesus Christ. That is the first touchstone. There is another touchstone in this section. That is the question about whom the audience is for the message of a person who presents himself as a teacher (see 1 John 4:6). There is mention of a company of listeners that consists of those who are from God and a company of those who are from the world. Those who are from God, listen to the apostles; those who are from the world, listen to the spirit of the antichrist.
John starts with addressing you as ‘beloved’. That is a wonderful starting point for the old apostle. It expresses his care for you. Out of that care he wants to warn you to not accept all kinds of nice talks about God and His Son as if those words automatically come from God. You may think that it is alright as soon as you hear someone talks about God and Jesus. That is certainly not alright. You ought to test the spirits and you ought to know from which resource they speak.
There are examples in the Bible which show that sometimes unbelievers have prophesied through the Spirit of God, like Balaam (Numbers 24:2). What he then said (Num 23-24) came from the right source. When he counseled the people against the Word of God to commit harlotry, he spoke from a wrong source (Numbers 25:1; Numbers 31:16).
It is not said that you should test people to know whether they are believers or that they share the right doctrine, but it is about testing spirits. It is not about an orthodox confession, but about the question from which source the people speak. Is the source the Holy Spirit or is it a demonic spirit? That is the question here. It is about unmasking people who present themselves as prophets and claim to come up with a message from God, while in reality they bring the lie and therefore speak through a demonic spirit.
It is about spirits that imitate the work of the Holy Spirit. The spirit of the islam for example is clearly a demonic spirit and not an imitation spirit. The case with the false prophets who went out, is different. They imitate the Spirit of God, behind which of course a demonic spirit was hidden. That they “have gone out”, indicates an activity. Activity always impress people. What also is impressive, is that they are with a lot of them. You may have an idea about that kind of influence. When many people claim something, it impresses more than when an individual says it.
1 John 4:2. The touchstone is the way people think about the Lord Jesus. The Holy Spirit only reveals what serves to the glorification of the Lord Jesus and He does that with joy. Satan and his angels are doing the reverse. They talk nicely, but there is nothing that glorifies Him. On the contrary, they seek to dishonor Him. It is not only about historical salvation facts, but also about facts related with the Person of Christ. He is to be confessed as the Word that really became flesh (John 1:14).
He has not put on the form of blood and flesh temporarily. That He came “in the flesh” means that He became Man. The fact that He is Man means that from the moment He became that it was indissolubly connected to His Person. He truly became Man and He will be that forever. If He would not be Man anymore now, then that means that He had never been truly Man.
That He “has come in the flesh”, implies by definition that He has always existed as God. A person can only come in the flesh when He has a preexistence as God. He has eternally existed as the eternal Son. The confession that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh, is therefore also a confession of the eternal Godhead of the Lord Jesus.
1 John 4:3. When you talk about the Lord Jesus with somebody and no clear confession about Him comes out of his mouth, then it is not right. Such a person is not of God, meaning that he is not born of God (1 John 3:9-2 Samuel :). Not being able to make this confession means that such a person has not been born again.
A person who is born of God and therefore has new life, loves the Lord Jesus. That will also be noticeable. Saying that you love Him without showing anything of it, is telling a lie. It is about the confession of ‘Jesus’. Where you meet new life, there will be no need for an extensive explanation of Him. Family members immediately recognize one another.
The spirit of the antichrist does not confess Jesus as having come in the flesh. It is not only about what this spirit says, but also about the whole spirit in which he comes and acts (2 Thessalonians 2:3). It is someone who does not confess Jesus and furthermore in no way he considers God. The antichrist is the man in whom sin is in its fullness. The antichrist as a person is still to come, but his spirit is now already in the world. That spirit is not of God, but comes from satan.
1 John 4:4. What should you do when you notice that you are dealing with such a spirit? You do not have to do anything. You may know something and that is that you are a conqueror of that spirit. You have not overcome him by winning a discussion. You should not even start a discussion, for then you will on the contrary be defeated. Eve went into a conversation with the devil and she was the loser. You do not need to know and rebuke all arguments of the adversaries. You should simply stick to what you have been taught from the beginning, which is to the truth that was manifested to you through the apostles.
You are born of God and you may see yourself in the position of conqueror, because you have the Holy Spirit within you through the faith in the Name of the Son of God. So you don’t need to ask who is greater, the Spirit Who is in you or the spirit in the world. Therefore you should not let yourself be impressed by the parade of spirits who try to fool you by saying that you are a follower of a pitiable faith and that they can introduce higher forms of truth to you. Hold on to the faith that you have heard from the beginning and behave like a conqueror and the enemy will flee (1 John 5:4).
1 John 4:5. The followers and proclaimers of the false doctrine “are from the world”. That’s their origin and there they are at home. Everything that comes from them is what they are and where they belong. That corresponds to all who belong to the world and not to the believers. The world is under the power of satan and he rules it. From that evil system he sends his demons to dispose of their pestiferous doctrines. What they bring perfectly corresponds with the people who belong to the world. Those people listen to them, because they speak the same language as the men of the world.
1 John 4:6. You do not belong to the world anymore. That’s why you do not listen to them. Because you know God you listen to the apostles, for they “are from God”. It is about a radical contrast, the contrast between truth and error. There is absolutely no relation between those two. Therefore there is also no relation between those who are of God and those who are not of God. The unbeliever doesn’t understand anything from what you as a child of God receive with love. He doesn’t listen to it.
You can also apply the words “listens us” in a broader sense than to the apostles alone. You may apply them to all who proclaim the Word of God. Then it is about the word of the apostles, in other words the inspired Word of God. Then you’ll love to listen to teachers who explain God’s Word to you and edify you in your faith. They do not point to themselves and they also do not try to win you for their ideas, but they point to Christ. If you hear them, it will find connection in your heart, because the Spirit dwells in there.
Actually, that will only happen if the words that you hear are in accordance with the Scripture. Thereby it doesn’t matter by whom they are spoken, whether it is a well-known preacher or a totally unknown believer. The touch stone is God’s Word, the written Word. When that is spoken under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, you will listen to it.
Now read 1 John 4:1-6 again.
Reflection: How do you know from what spirit something comes?